What is the difference between a Cackling Goose and a Canadian goose?

Answered by Douglas Hiatt

The Cackling Goose and the Canada Goose are two species of geese that can often be confused due to their similar appearance. However, there are several key differences between the two that can help in distinguishing them.

Size is one of the most noticeable differences between Cackling Geese and Canada Geese. Canada Geese are generally larger overall, with a longer neck and a larger bill. They can reach lengths of up to 40 inches and have a wingspan of around 60 inches. On the other hand, Cackling Geese are smaller, measuring around 20-25 inches in length and having a wingspan of about 40-45 inches. They have a relatively shorter neck and a smaller bill compared to Canada Geese. However, it’s important to note that there are some smaller subspecies of Canada Geese that can approach the size of Cackling Geese, so size alone may not be a definitive characteristic.

Another distinguishing feature is the shape of their heads. Canada Geese have a rounder head with a sloping forehead. Their profiles appear more curved due to the shape of their skull. In contrast, Cackling Geese have a steeper forehead, creating a more angular appearance. This difference in head shape can be helpful in identifying the two species.

In terms of plumage, both species can have similar coloration. They typically have brown bodies, grayish-brown backs, and a white chinstrap. However, Canada Geese often have a black head and neck, while Cackling Geese may have a darker head and neck with a lighter chinstrap. The specific color variations can vary among individuals and subspecies, so it’s important to consider other characteristics as well.

Behavior can also provide some clues for identification. Canada Geese are known for their honking calls, which can be loud and distinctive. They are often seen in large flocks and are known for their adaptability to urban environments. Cackling Geese, on the other hand, tend to have higher-pitched calls and are usually found in smaller groups. They are more commonly associated with open grasslands and agricultural fields.

It’s worth noting that both species can occasionally hybridize, resulting in intermediate characteristics that can make identification more challenging. In such cases, it may be helpful to consult field guides or seek assistance from experienced birders or ornithologists.

While Cackling Geese and Canada Geese share some similarities in appearance, there are several differences that can aid in their identification. These include size, head shape, plumage variations, and behavior. By paying attention to these distinguishing features, birdwatchers can better differentiate between the two species.