Does all charcoal need to be GREY before cooking?

Answered by Edward Huber

Not all charcoal needs to be completely grey before cooking. While it is generally a good indication that the charcoal is ready for cooking, there are some factors to consider. Let’s dive into the details.

1. Charcoal Types and Brands:
Different types of charcoal and brands may have varying characteristics when it comes to readiness for cooking. Some brands may produce charcoal that turns grey quicker, while others may take longer. It’s important to read the instructions or recommendations provided by the manufacturer to determine the optimal readiness.

2. Cooking Method:
The cooking method you are using can also impact when the charcoal is ready. For example, if you are grilling over direct heat, you may want to wait until the charcoal has turned mostly grey to ensure even and consistent heat distribution. On the other hand, if you are using indirect heat for slow cooking or smoking, the charcoal may not need to be completely grey before you start cooking.

3. Temperature Control:
If you are looking for high heat cooking, such as searing a steak, you may want to wait until the charcoal has turned mostly grey to ensure a hot cooking surface. However, for lower temperature cooking, like slow roasting or smoking, you can start cooking when the charcoal has reached a lower temperature and has a mix of grey and black coals.

4. Personal Preference:
Ultimately, the readiness of the charcoal can also depend on your personal preference and experience. Some people prefer a fully grey charcoal bed for consistent heat, while others may find that a mix of grey and black coals works just as well.

In my personal experience, I have found that waiting until most of the charcoal has turned grey is a good rule of thumb for most cooking situations. It typically ensures that the charcoal is hot and ready for cooking, providing a good balance of heat and longevity. However, there may be instances where slightly less grey charcoal can still be suitable, depending on the factors mentioned above.

To summarize, while waiting until most of the charcoal has turned grey/got white is generally a good practice, it is not an absolute requirement for all cooking situations. It’s important to consider the type of charcoal, cooking method, desired temperature, and personal preference to determine the optimal readiness for cooking.