When considering who is higher between Elrond and Thranduil, it is important to understand the context of their roles and positions within their respective realms. Elrond is the Lord of Rivendell, also known as Imladris, and Thranduil is the King of the Woodland Realm, also known as Mirkwood. Both characters hold significant power and influence, but their authority and status differ.
Firstly, Elrond is a half-elf, being the son of Eärendil and Elwing. He is a descendant of both elves and men, and his lineage traces back to the ancient elf-lords of the First Age. This gives Elrond a unique position and a strong claim to kingship. However, he chooses not to pursue such a title and instead focuses on being a wise and compassionate guardian of Rivendell.
On the other hand, Thranduil is a pure-blooded elf and the son of Oropher, who was the King of the Woodland Realm before him. Thranduil’s authority and claim to kingship are based on his bloodline and the inherited rule from his father. This gives him a more direct and traditional claim to the throne.
In terms of power and influence, both Elrond and Thranduil are highly respected and revered within their respective realms. Elrond is known for his wisdom, knowledge, and healing abilities. He is also a member of the White Council, a group of powerful beings who protect Middle-earth from the forces of darkness. Elrond’s role as a lore-master and counselor grants him significant influence.
Thranduil, on the other hand, is renowned for his military prowess and the protection of his kingdom. He is a skilled warrior and a shrewd leader, effectively ruling over his people and defending them from the dangers of Mirkwood. Thranduil’s authority comes from his ability to maintain the safety and prosperity of his realm, making him a respected figure among his subjects.
It is worth noting that both Elrond and Thranduil could potentially claim the title of King, but they have chosen different paths. Elrond’s decision to be a guardian and protector of Rivendell rather than an authoritarian ruler may stem from his experiences during the First Age, where the desire for power and kingship led to great tragedy and destruction. Similarly, Thranduil’s focus on being a strong and protective leader rather than a king could be influenced by the shadow that lies over Mirkwood and the constant threat from the dark forces that dwell there.
While both Elrond and Thranduil hold significant positions of power and influence, their authority and status differ. Elrond’s strong claim to kingship is overshadowed by his choice to be a guardian of Rivendell, while Thranduil’s direct lineage and role as the King of the Woodland Realm give him a more traditional claim to the throne. Ultimately, both characters have decided to prioritize the well-being of their realms rather than pursuing the title of king.