Why is coffee called the devil’s brew?

Answered by Douglas Hiatt

Coffee is often referred to as the “devil’s brew” due to its historical association with sin and temptation. This nickname stems from the belief held by some religious groups, including certain factions within the Catholic Church, that coffee was a sinful and immoral beverage.

During the 16th and 17th centuries, when coffee was first introduced to Europe, it faced significant opposition from various religious and political factions. Some clergy members and religious leaders believed that the stimulating effects of coffee were unnatural and could lead people away from a pious and sober lifestyle. They considered coffee to be a product of the devil, as it was believed to incite sinful behavior and undermine religious devotion.

This perception of coffee as a sinful drink was further reinforced by its association with social gatherings and intellectual discourse. Coffeehouses, which emerged in the 17th century, became popular meeting places for lively debates and discussions. These establishments were seen as hotbeds of political dissent and intellectual rebellion, leading to further condemnation of coffee by religious authorities.

The Catholic Church, in particular, had a conflicted relationship with coffee. While some members of the clergy vehemently opposed its consumption, others saw potential benefits in using coffee as a way to combat the excessive consumption of alcohol, which was prevalent at the time. Pope Clement VIII, as mentioned in the legend, famously decided to taste coffee before making a decision on whether to ban it. His positive reaction to the beverage may have helped sway the Church’s stance and prevented a complete prohibition.

Despite these initial reservations, coffee gradually gained acceptance and popularity, even among religious communities. As time passed, the negative associations with coffee as a sinful drink faded, and it became more widely accepted as a socially and culturally significant beverage.

It is important to note that the term “devil’s brew” is primarily a historical reference and is not widely used in modern times. Coffee is now enjoyed by people of various religious backgrounds, and its consumption is not typically viewed as morally objectionable.

Coffee was once called the “devil’s brew” due to its association with sin, temptation, and intellectual rebellion. However, as societal attitudes changed and coffee gained wider acceptance, this label lost its significance. Today, coffee is enjoyed by millions of people around the world without any moral or religious implications.