Why do males retain their tusks when 50% of females lost them?

Answered by Jeremy Urbaniak

The retention of tusks in males can be attributed to their role in intra-sexual competition for mates. In many species, including elephants and walruses, males engage in battles with other males to establish dominance and gain access to females. Tusks are formidable weapons that provide males with a significant advantage in these fights. As a result, males without tusks are more likely to be wounded or overpowered by their tusked counterparts, making them less successful in securing mates and passing on their genes.

In the case of elephants, tusks are elongated incisor teeth that grow throughout their lives. These massive structures can reach impressive lengths and are used for various purposes, including digging, foraging, and manipulating objects. However, their primary function in male elephants is combat. During the mating season, known as musth, males engage in intense battles to establish dominance and gain access to receptive females. Tusks act as formidable weapons, allowing males to inflict serious injuries on their opponents and establish their superiority.

The fact that only around 50% of female elephants possess tusks can be attributed to sexual dimorphism, which is the physical differences between males and females of a species. In elephants, tusklessness is a heritable trait that is passed down from generation to generation. It is believed that tusklessness in females is an evolutionary adaptation to avoid the costs associated with having large, cumbersome tusks. While tusks may provide certain advantages in terms of foraging and defense, the benefits do not outweigh the costs for females. Therefore, over time, a higher proportion of females have evolved to be tuskless.

It is important to note that tusklessness in females is not universal and can vary among elephant populations. In some areas, such as certain parts of Africa, a significant proportion of females still retain their tusks. This variation can be influenced by a combination of genetic factors and selective pressures exerted by the environment. For instance, in areas where poaching for ivory is rampant, there may be a higher prevalence of tusklessness as poachers specifically target elephants with tusks. This selective pressure can lead to a higher proportion of tuskless females in the population.

While tusks are primarily associated with male-male competition in elephants, it is worth mentioning that they also play a role in female-female interactions. Female elephants with tusks may use them for dominance displays and resolving conflicts within their social groups. However, the importance of tusks in female-female interactions is generally considered to be secondary compared to their significance in male-male competition.

The retention of tusks in males can be attributed to their role in intra-sexual competition for mates. Males without tusks are more likely to be wounded or overpowered by tusked males, reducing their chances of survival and reproductive success. On the other hand, tusklessness in females is an evolutionary adaptation to avoid the costs associated with having large tusks. However, the prevalence of tusklessness can vary among populations and is influenced by genetic factors and selective pressures.