In my experience, I have found that the Silver Pinap is definitely a superior choice compared to the Golden Razz Berry. Let me explain why.
First, let’s talk about catch rates. The Silver Pinap offers a catch rate multiplier of 1.7x, whereas the Golden Razz Berry has a multiplier of 2.5x. At first glance, it may seem like the Golden Razz Berry is the better option since it has a higher multiplier. However, it’s important to note that the catch rate increase is not linear. For example, going from a base catch rate of 2% to 3% is a 50% increase, while going from 10% to 12.5% is only a 25% increase. This means that the additional 0.8x catch rate increase provided by the Golden Razz Berry is not as significant as it may initially appear.
On the other hand, the Silver Pinap’s 1.7x catch rate multiplier is still quite substantial. It offers a significant boost to your chances of catching the boss Pokémon. While it may not be as high as the Golden Razz Berry, it is important to consider the overall effectiveness.
Additionally, the Silver Pinap offers the added benefit of doubling the number of candies you receive when catching a Pokémon. This is a huge advantage, especially when it comes to catching raid bosses. More candies means more opportunities to power up or evolve your Pokémon, making them stronger and more competitive in battles. This can be particularly valuable when trying to obtain rare or legendary Pokémon.
Now, let’s talk about availability and resource management. Golden Razz Berries are much rarer and harder to come by compared to Silver Pinaps. Golden Razz Berries are typically obtained through raids or as a reward for defending gyms. On the other hand, Silver Pinaps are more readily available and can be obtained through various means, such as research tasks, spinning Pokéstops, or as rewards for completing special events. This means that you can stock up on Silver Pinaps more easily and have a larger supply to use in your encounters.
In my personal experience, I have found that using Silver Pinaps in raids has been highly effective. I have caught a significant number of raid bosses using Silver Pinaps, and the extra candies have been extremely valuable in powering up my Pokémon. It has allowed me to quickly strengthen my team and be more competitive in battles.
To summarize, while the Golden Razz Berry may offer a higher catch rate multiplier, the Silver Pinap’s catch rate increase is still significant. Additionally, the doubled candy bonus provided by the Silver Pinap is a huge advantage, allowing for more opportunities to enhance your Pokémon. Considering the availability and resource management, the Silver Pinap is a better option in my opinion.