How to tell the difference between short billed Dowitcher and Yellowlegs?

Answered by Jason Smith

To tell the difference between a short-billed dowitcher and a yellowlegs, there are a few key characteristics to look out for. First, let’s focus on the features that distinguish the two species in terms of their physical appearance.

Plumage is a good starting point. Short-billed dowitchers will typically have a range of brown, rufous, and buff colors in their breeding plumage, while in winter, they tend to have a mostly flat gray plumage. On the other hand, yellowlegs have a plumage that consists of tones of grays, often with flecks of black. This difference in coloration can be quite helpful in distinguishing between the two species.

Another important feature to consider is leg length and color. Greater yellowlegs, in particular, have long legs that are quite noticeable. Their legs are a bright yellow color, which stands out in comparison to the dowitcher’s legs. Dowitchers, on the other hand, have relatively shorter legs that are not as vibrant in coloration. The yellowlegs’ longer and brighter legs are a key characteristic that can help differentiate them from dowitchers.

Understanding the behavior and habitat preferences of these birds can also provide valuable clues for identification. Short-billed dowitchers are more commonly found in freshwater habitats, such as marshes, ponds, and mudflats. They tend to forage by probing their bills in the mud for food, such as insects and small crustaceans. Yellowlegs, on the other hand, are more often found in a wider range of habitats, including both freshwater and saltwater environments. They have a distinctive feeding behavior, repeatedly and rapidly stabbing at the water or ground to catch prey.

In terms of size, yellowlegs are generally larger than dowitchers. Greater yellowlegs, as the name suggests, are the larger of the two species. However, size alone may not always be the most reliable characteristic for identification, as there can be some overlap in size between individuals.

To summarize the key differences between short-billed dowitchers and yellowlegs:

1. Plumage: Dowitchers have a range of brown, rufous, and buff colors in breeding plumage, whereas yellowlegs have tones of grays with flecks of black. In winter, dowitchers have mostly flat gray plumage, while yellowlegs maintain their gray tones.

2. Leg length and color: Yellowlegs have long, bright yellow legs, while dowitchers have relatively shorter and less vibrant legs.

3. Behavior and habitat: Dowitchers are often found in freshwater habitats and probe their bills in the mud for food, while yellowlegs can be found in various habitats and have a distinct feeding behavior of stabbing at water or ground.

4. Size: Yellowlegs are generally larger than dowitchers, with greater yellowlegs being the larger of the two species.

By considering these various characteristics, you can enhance your ability to differentiate between short-billed dowitchers and yellowlegs. It is always helpful to observe multiple features in combination rather than relying on a single characteristic for identification.