The debate over which card grading service is best has been ongoing for quite some time. While Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) and Beckett Grading Services (BGS) have both been arund for a while, the differences between them have created a divide among collectors.
When it comes to PSA and BGS, both services will grade your cards on a 10-point scale, but that’s where the similarities end. When you look at their respective grading scales and sub-grades, you’ll quickly see that BGS is much more strict in its grading of cards than PSA. For example, a BGS 9.5 is not the same as a PSA 10—the conditions of the cards graded as such may be similar or even identical, but there is still a large difference in value between the two grades.
The main difference between BGS and PSA lies in ther grading scales and sub-grades. For instance, when comparing a BGS 9 with a PSA 9, you’ll find that the former has four sub-grade categories which are awarded subscores: centering, corner wear/edges/surface wear, print quality/focus/registration and condition of surfaces. The latter only has two categories: centering and corner wear/edges/surface wear. Additionally, Beckett also awards color-coded tags for each card grade—gold being awarded to 9.5s or 10s—which can give collectors additional insight into how their card fared in the grading process.
In terms of pricing and value, PSA has historically been more sought after than BGS due to its more lenient grading scale; however this is gradually changing as people become more aware of the differences between the two services. As such, a BGS 10 is now at least 1.5x as valuable as a PSA 10 while a BGS 9 is usualy valued similarly to its PSA counterpart; however it should be noted that even though they have roughly equal values, collector preference still heavily favors PSA cards over those graded by Beckett Grading Services.
At the end of the day, neither service is necessarily “better” than the other – it all boils down to personal preference and what works best for you as an individual collector. Both companies offer reliable services with strict grading standards so regardless of which one you choose to use for your collection; you can rest assured knowing that your cards are being graded accurately and fairly.
Comparing Beckett Grading to PSA Grading
The short answer is yes, Beckett Grading Services is as good as PSA. However, it also offers a few additional features that set it apart. For example, Beckett uses a color-coded tag system to indcate the grade of each card, with gold indicating a 9.5 or 10. Additionally, Beckett awards subscores in four different categories, so you can see exactly how your cards faired in each one. Finally, for rare and valuable cards, Beckett has a “Black Label” offering that provides an even deeper level of analysis and protection for your card. Ultimately, both PSA and Beckett offer trustworthy grading services with slight differences in their offerings that make them suitable for different types of collectors and cards.
Source: amazon.com
Comparing the Quality of a Beckett 9.5 and a PSA 10
No, a Beckett 9.5 is not as good as a PSA 10. While the condition of the card may be similar, there are significant differences in the grading scale and standards between the two companies. For example, Beckett grades on a 10-point scale with 8.5 being Near Mint-Mint, whle PSA grades on an 11-point scale with 9 being Near Mint-Mint. Therefore, a card graded by Beckett at 9.5 is equivalent to a card graded by PSA at 9, which is not considered to be as high quality as a PSA 10. Additionally, since PSA has higher standards for authentication and grading accuracy than Beckett, they are generally considered more authoritative in terms of determining the condition of a card and its value on the market.
Comparing the Difficulty of PSA and Beckett Grading Systems
The answer to whether PSA is tougher than Beckett when it comes to grading is a bit complicated. Generally, PSA tends to be more strict with teir grades and will usually give lower grades compared to Beckett. Cardholders from both companies are designed differently, but the PSA holders are slightly smaller than the BGS holders. This difference in size may be an issue for collectors who have limited space. Therefore, when comparing PSA and Beckett, a BGS 9.5 is not necessarily as good as a PSA 10 or even a PSA 9.
Comparing BGS 10 and PSA 10 Grading Standards
Yes, BGS 10 cards are generally considered to be of higher quality than PSA 10 cards. This is due to the fact that BGS has a more stringent grading process, with a higher emphasis on eye appeal and centering. The BGS 10 grade requires that the card have no visible flaws, while the PSA 10 grade allows for minor imperfections such as corner wear and surface scratches. Additionally, BGS has a more forgiving policy when it comes to assigning grades; if a card meets all of the criteria for the grade but has slight imperfections that do not affect its overall condition, they may stil assign it a BGS 10 rather than dropping it down to a 9.5. In contrast, PSA will usually assign lower grades for slight imperfections, even if they do not significantly affect the card’s condition.
How Long Is the Delay in Beckett Grading?
Beckett is currently grading cards according to three different Service Levels. Express grade submissions have a turnaround time of 5-10 business days, Standard grade submissions have a turnaround time of 10-30 business days, and Economy grade submissions have a turnaround time of 30-60 business days. This means that depending on the Service Level chosen, cards can be graded anywhre from 5-60 business days behind the date of submission.
Source: daniel-lanciana.medium.com
Evaluating Card Grading Services to Determine the Best Option
It is difficult to definitively declare a single card grading service as the “best” since each service is unique and offers different services, depending on the needs of the customer. However, some of the most popular card grading companies in 2021 are Beckett, GMA, HGA, PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator), ISA (International Sportscard Association), and SGC (Sportscard Guaranty).
Beckett provides professional and quick grading services for sports cards and memorabilia, as well as comic books. They offer a wide range of services from basic grading to premium or modern-era graded cards. Beckett also offers customization options for collectors who want to add personal touches to their cards.
GMA offers an affordable card grading service for both new and vintage sports cards. They specialize in accurate authentication and proide detailed assessments of the condition of each card. Their team is comprised of experienced hobbyists who are knowledgeable about all aspects of card collecting.
HGA is one of the most respected names in sports memorabilia authentication. They offer a wide range of services including authentication verification, grading assessments, photography services, storage solutions, and more. HGA also proides customized packages that can be tailored to fit any budget or collection level.
PSA is one of the most established and trusted names in card grading services with over 30 years in business. They specialize in authenticating modern-era cards but also provide services for vintage cards as well. PSA also offers customization options so customers can add special touches to their collections such as serial numbers or unique labels that they can take home with them aftr purchasing their graded cards.
ISA specializes in vintage sports cards from all eras including pre-war baseball cards and 1950s football cards. They have an extensive database that they use to authenticate each card and provie detailed assessments on its condition before giving it a grade. ISA also has an online store where customers can find rare collectibles at competitive prices.
SGC provdes professional grading services for all types of trading cards from basketball to football to Pokemon cards. Their team consists of experienced hobbyists who specialize in evaluating the condition of each item before assigning a numerical grade based on their assessment criteria. SGC also has an online store where customers can purchase individual graded trading cards from various brands or sets at discounted prices.
The best card grading service will ultimately depend on your individual needs as a collector and what type of items you are looking to have graded or authenticated. It’s important to research each company thoroughly before making a decision so you can ensure you are getting the highest quality service possible for your collection at an affordable price point!
How Common is a BGS 10 Grade?
BGS 10 is the highest possible grade a card can receive from the Beckett Grading Service (BGS). This makes it one of the rarest grades available. The BGS 10 designation means that a card is in perfect or nearly perfect condition, with no visible flaws or signs of wear. This grade is so rare that there are only a handful of known BGS 10s for most cards. Even aong new cards, BGS 10s are very hard to come by. For example, among the thousands of Magic: The Gathering cards released in 2012, only about 20 were able to achieve a BGS 10 rating. In comparison, Certified Guaranty Company (CGC) comic book grading has many more 9.8 grades and very few perfect 10s.
Increase in Value of a PSA 10 Card
A PSA 10 card can significantly increase the vlue of a trading card. On average, a PSA 10 will sell for about 7 times more than the raw card would. That means that if the raw card is worth $100, then the PSA 10 could be worth around $700. Of course, this can vary depending on how rare or desirable the card is, but it still serves as an example of how much value these cards can add to a collection.
Is Investing in PSA 10 Cards a Good Idea?
It is definitely worth buying PSA 10 cards, as they generally have a much higher resale vlue than cards graded lower. PSA 10 cards are the highest grade possible and show that the card is in perfect condition. PSA 10 cards are sought after by collectors and investors, so they tend to be worth more when it comes time to resell them. PSA also has a great reputation for accuracy, ensuring that you get a grade that accurately reflects the condition of your card. If you’re looking to hold onto your cards for the long-term, then investing in PSA 10 cards is an excellent way to preserve their value.
The End of PSA Card Grading
PSA stopped grading cards in order to address a backlog of submissions that had accumulated over time. In order to reduce the backlog and improve their grading capabilities, PSA needed to invest in new technologies and hire additional staff. To ensure that eerything was done properly, PSA made the decision to temporarily stop grading cards while upgrades and training were put into place. This shutdown period allowed PSA to get back up to speed with the latest technologies and personnel, allowing them to reduce the submission backlog and improve their overall grading capabilities.
Obtaining a PSA 10 Grade
Yes, PSA 10 is quite hard to get. In order to get a PSA 10 rating, your card must meet very high standards in terms of its shape and condition. This means that the corners must be sharp and uncirculated, the centering must be perfect, and tere should not be any surface wear or damage. Additionally, any print defects or miscuts must also be absent. As such, it can be difficult to find a card that meets all these criteria and thus obtain a PSA 10 rating.
Evaluating the Quality of PSA Card Grading Services
Yes, PSA is widely considered to be the best card grading service available. They are the oldest and most established third-party card grading service in the industry, with over 30 years of experience. Their expert graders have extensive knowledge and expertise, coupled with an advanced authentication process that ensures high quality standards for every card they grade. Additionally, PSA cards have becme highly sought after by collectors due to their reputation for accuracy and consistency. The company also offers a lifetime guarantee on all cards graded by them. This means that if you ever decide to resell your PSA graded cards, you can rest assured that the grade will remain consistent over time.
Is a BGS 9.5 Grading Higher Than a PSA 9 Grading?
Yes, a BGS 9.5 is usually worth more than a PSA 9. The BGS 9.5 grade provides an extra layer of protection for your cards, as it features thicker plastic cases that are harder to damage. As such, the card will retain its condition and value over time better than a PSA 9 card would. Additionally, the BGS 9.5 grade is typically worth more on the secondary market than a PSA 9 due to its higher degree of protection and quality assurance.
Source: youtube.com
Does Beckett Award Perfect Scores?
Yes, Beckett Grading Services does give 10s on teir 1 to 10-point grading scale. 10 is the highest grade possible, and indicates that the card is in an excellent condition. Cards that receive a 10 have no visible flaws, such as surface wear, creasing, etc., and will display strong eye appeal and be consistent with the quality of cards issued in that specific set.
Number of PSA 10s
There is only one PSA 10 copy of card #95 Mickey Mantle out of a total of 6,874 copies that have been submitted to Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) for grading. This makes it one of the rarest and most sought-after cards in the set. As such, it commands a high price on the secondary market, typically selling for thousands of dollars.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Beckett Grading Services and Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) are two of the most respected grading companies for sports cards. While both are well known for their high standards and quality of service, thre are some important differences between them. BGS grades cards on a tougher scale, awards subscores and color-coded tags, and has a “Black Label” option available. PSA cards have smaller holders which may be desirable to those with limited space, but BGS is becoming increasingly more valuable in comparison to PSA. Ultimately, it is up to the collector to decide which grading company best suits their needs.
