Why does beer have a head but not soda?

Answered by Randy McIntyre

When it comes to the question of why beer has a head but soda does not, there are a few factors at play. One of the main reasons is the presence of carbon dioxide (CO2) in both beverages. However, the way the CO2 interacts with the liquid differs between beer and soda.

In beer, the carbonation is a result of the fermentation process. During fermentation, yeast consumes sugars in the beer and produces alcohol and CO2 as byproducts. This CO2 is then dissolved in the liquid, creating carbonation. When the beer is poured into a glass, the CO2 begins to escape from the liquid and rise to the surface, forming bubbles.

Now, here’s where things get interesting. In beer, there is a compound called LTP1 (lipid transfer protein 1) that is present in the barley used to make the beer. LTP1 has the unique ability to cling to CO2 bubbles and rise to the surface along with them. As it does so, LTP1 forms a protective coating around the bubble, making it more difficult to pop. This is what helps beer maintain its head for a longer period of time compared to soda or hard cider.

On the other hand, soda typically contains carbonation that is artificially added during the manufacturing process. This is done by pressurizing the liquid with CO2, which is then dissolved into the soda. However, soda does not contain compounds like LTP1 that can form a protective coating around the bubbles. As a result, the carbonation in soda tends to dissipate more quickly, leading to a lack of head formation.

It’s also worth mentioning that the ingredients used in beer and soda can contribute to the difference in head retention. Beer is brewed using malted barley, which contains proteins that can enhance foam stability. Additionally, certain hops used in brewing beer can also have foam-positive properties. In contrast, soda is typically made with water, sweeteners, and artificial flavorings, which do not provide the same foaming characteristics.

So, in summary, the presence of LTP1 in beer, along with the proteins and hops used in brewing, contributes to its ability to maintain a head. Meanwhile, soda lacks these components and relies solely on artificially added carbonation, resulting in a lack of head formation.