Why are carbonates not soluble?

Answered by Antonio Sutton

Carbonates, such as calcium carbonate (CaCO3), are generally considered insoluble in water. This means that they do not readily dissolve or dissociate into individual ions in water. The lack of solubility can be attributed to the strong electrostatic bonds between the carbonate anion (CO32-) and the calcium ion (Ca2+). These bonds are formed due to the attraction between the positively charged calcium ion and the negatively charged carbonate ion.

The carbonate anion consists of three oxygen atoms bonded to a central carbon atom, giving it a net charge of -2. This negative charge is balanced by the presence of the calcium ion, which carries a charge of +2. The electrostatic attraction between the oppositely charged ions leads to the formation of a solid lattice structure in the carbonate compound.

When a carbonate compound is placed in water, the water molecules surround the ions in a process called solvation. The partially positively charged hydrogen atoms in water molecules are attracted to the negatively charged carbonate anion, while the partially negatively charged oxygen atoms in water molecules are attracted to the positively charged calcium ion.

However, despite the solvation process, the electrostatic bonds between the carbonate anion and the calcium ion remain too strong to be overcome by the surrounding water molecules. The energy required to break these bonds and separate the ions is considerable, and the water molecules are not able to provide enough energy to dissolve the carbonate compound.

Additionally, the carbonate ion forms stable compounds with many metal ions, including calcium, magnesium, and iron. These compounds, known as carbonates, are generally insoluble in water due to the strong bonds formed between the carbonate anion and the metal cation. This insolubility is further reinforced by the lattice structure of the carbonate compound, which makes it difficult for water molecules to penetrate and disrupt the structure.

It is worth mentioning that there are exceptions to the general insolubility of carbonates. Some carbonates, such as those of alkali metals (e.g., sodium carbonate) and ammonium carbonate, are soluble in water. This is because these carbonates have weaker electrostatic bonds and their lattice structures are more easily disrupted by water molecules.

The limited solubility of carbonates in water can be attributed to the strong electrostatic bonds between the carbonate anion and the metal cation, such as calcium ion. These bonds, along with the stable lattice structure, prevent the easy dissociation of carbonate compounds into individual ions in water.