Which is better metal or plastic cocktail shaker?

Answered by Jarrod Smith

When it comes to choosing between a metal or plastic cocktail shaker, there are several factors to consider. In my personal experience, I have found that metal shakers offer several advantages over their plastic counterparts.

Firstly, metal cocktail shakers are known for their durability and longevity. Unlike plastic shakers, which can easily crack or break with regular use, metal shakers are built to last. I have used a stainless steel cocktail shaker for years without any signs of wear and tear. This not only saves you money in the long run, but it also reduces waste as you won’t need to constantly replace your shaker.

Another advantage of metal shakers is their ability to retain temperature. When making cocktails, it is often important to chill or shake the ingredients to achieve the desired taste and consistency. Metal shakers have excellent insulation properties, allowing them to retain cold temperatures for longer periods. This is especially beneficial when making drinks that require shaking with ice, as the metal shaker will keep the cocktail colder for a longer time, resulting in a more refreshing and enjoyable drink.

Furthermore, metal shakers are generally easier to clean compared to plastic ones. They are often dishwasher safe, which makes the cleaning process quick and hassle-free. Plastic shakers, on the other hand, can become stained or retain odors over time, requiring more effort to keep them clean.

In terms of aesthetics, metal shakers also have an advantage. They often have a sleek and polished appearance, adding a touch of sophistication to your home bar or cocktail-making experience. Plastic shakers, on the other hand, can look cheap and may not complement the overall ambiance you are trying to create.

One common concern with metal shakers is their weight. They are generally heavier than plastic shakers, which can be a drawback for some people, especially if you plan on using them for extended periods or if you have limited arm strength. However, I have found that the added weight actually helps with the shaking process, providing better control and distribution of the ingredients.

Lastly, it is worth mentioning that metal shakers are a more environmentally friendly option. Plastic shakers contribute to the growing issue of plastic waste and pollution. By choosing a metal shaker, you are making a conscious decision to reduce your plastic consumption and minimize your impact on the environment.

While both metal and plastic cocktail shakers have their pros and cons, I believe that metal shakers offer several advantages that make them a better choice overall. They are durable, retain temperature better, easier to clean, aesthetically pleasing, and environmentally friendly. So, if you are looking for a reliable and long-lasting cocktail shaker, I would highly recommend considering a metal one.