What’s the difference between Captain Morgan and Captain Morgan Black?

Answered by Phillip Nicastro

When it comes to comparing Captain Morgan and Captain Morgan Black, there are several noticeable differences that set them apart. Let’s delve into the details and uncover what makes Captain Morgan Black a step up from the traditional Captain Morgan Spiced Rum.

1. Ingredients: One of the key distinctions between the two is the choice of ingredients. While both rums are made from molasses, Captain Morgan Black incorporates a blackstrap rum, which is a type of molasses-based rum known for its rich and robust flavor. This gives Captain Morgan Black a deeper and more complex taste profile compared to the original Captain Morgan.

2. Aging Process: Another factor that contributes to the difference in flavor is the aging process. Captain Morgan Black is aged in double charred oak barrels, which imparts additional smokiness and depth to the rum. In contrast, the regular Captain Morgan Spiced Rum is not aged for as long or in the same type of barrels, resulting in a milder flavor profile.

3. Spice Blend: Both Captain Morgan and Captain Morgan Black are spiced rums, but the spice blend used in Captain Morgan Black is slightly different. The black variant tends to have a more pronounced and bolder spice profile, with hints of clove, cinnamon, and nutmeg. This intensified spiciness adds another layer of complexity to the overall taste experience.

4. Flavor Intensity: As a result of the aforementioned factors, Captain Morgan Black offers a more intense and robust flavor compared to the regular Captain Morgan Spiced Rum. The black variant tends to have a fuller body, with a richer and more satisfying taste that lingers on the palate. It’s a rum that truly stands out and demands attention.

5. Versatility: While both rums can be enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or in cocktails, the boldness of Captain Morgan Black makes it a great choice for those who prefer a stronger and more distinctive rum flavor. It pairs exceptionally well with mixers like cola, ginger beer, or even in more complex cocktails where its unique flavor can shine.

Personal experience-wise, I’ve had the pleasure of trying both Captain Morgan and Captain Morgan Black, and I must say that the black variant truly impressed me. The depth of flavor, the spiciness, and the lingering notes made it a standout choice for sipping or mixing into cocktails. It brought a certain richness to the drinks that the regular Captain Morgan Spiced Rum couldn’t quite match.

Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum is a clear upgrade from the traditional Captain Morgan Spiced Rum. With its use of blackstrap rum, double charred oak barrel aging, intensified spice blend, and overall bolder flavor profile, Captain Morgan Black offers a more complex and satisfying rum experience. Whether enjoyed neat or incorporated into cocktails, it’s a rum that delivers on taste and leaves a lasting impression.