What is better for a puppy a collar or harness?

Answered by Phillip Nicastro

When it comes to choosing between a collar and a harness for your puppy, the consensus among experts is that a harness is the safer option, especially for activities such as going on walks or engaging in outdoor adventures. While a flat collar may be suitable for everyday wear and displaying ID tags, it is not the best choice when it comes to leash training or situations where your puppy may pull on the leash.

One of the main reasons a harness is preferred is because it reduces the risk of injury to your puppy’s neck and throat. Puppies have delicate necks, and if they pull forcefully on a collar, it can potentially cause damage to their windpipe or result in tracheal collapse. This is particularly important for small or toy breeds that are more prone to such injuries.

In addition to protecting your puppy’s neck, a harness also provides better control over their movements. When a leash is attached to a harness, the pressure is distributed across the puppy’s chest and shoulders, making it easier to guide them without causing discomfort or pain. This is especially beneficial if your puppy tends to pull or lunge during walks, as the harness prevents them from putting excessive pressure on their neck.

Moreover, a harness can also be helpful for puppies that are still learning leash manners. It allows you to redirect their attention and correct their behavior more effectively. For example, if your puppy starts to pull, you can gently guide them back to your side using the harness, promoting positive reinforcement and teaching them to walk calmly on a leash.

There are different types of harnesses available, so it’s important to choose one that is appropriate for your puppy’s size, breed, and specific needs. Adjustable harnesses are great for growing puppies, as they can be modified to accommodate their changing size. It’s essential to ensure that the harness fits properly and is snug but not too tight, as a poorly fitted harness may cause discomfort or rubbing.

Personally, I have found a harness to be immensely beneficial for my own puppy. When I first started leash training, she would constantly pull and strain against the collar, making walks both frustrating and potentially harmful for her neck. Switching to a harness made a noticeable difference in her behavior and comfort level. She now walks calmly and enjoys her outings without any strain on her neck.

To summarize, while a flat collar is suitable for everyday wear and displaying ID tags, a harness is the safer option for activities such as walking or outdoor adventures. It reduces the risk of neck injuries, provides better control over your puppy’s movements, and can aid in leash training. Remember to choose a well-fitted harness that suits your puppy’s needs and enjoy your walks together!