Should you shake breast milk?

Answered by Cody Janus

Shaking breast milk is a topic that I feel strongly about, as I have personally experienced the negative effects it can have on both baby and mother. It is important to understand why shaking breast milk is not recommended and the potential consequences it can have.

One of the main reasons why shaking breast milk is discouraged is because it can cause the baby to develop an aversion to the flavor of their food. Breast milk contains enzymes and proteins that are delicate and can be easily damaged by vigorous shaking. This can result in a bitter taste and unpleasant odor, which may cause the baby to refuse to drink the milk. As a new mother, I experienced this firsthand when my baby started rejecting breast milk after I had shaken it vigorously.

In addition to affecting the taste of breast milk, shaking can also alter the fat content and other nutrients in the milk. Breast milk naturally separates into layers, with the creamier, fatty portion rising to the top. Gentle swirling is recommended to mix the layers back together without damaging the delicate components of the milk. However, shaking can cause the fats to break down, leading to a loss of nutritional value. This was a concern for me as I wanted to ensure that my baby was receiving all the essential nutrients from my breast milk.

Furthermore, there is some evidence to suggest that shaking breast milk may increase the risk of colic in babies. Colic is a condition characterized by excessive, inconsolable crying in infants. While the exact cause of colic is still unknown, it is thought to be related to digestive issues and discomfort. Shaking breast milk vigorously can introduce air bubbles into the milk, which may contribute to gas and digestive problems in babies. As a mother who dealt with a colicky baby, I was cautious about anything that could potentially exacerbate the issue.

Based on my personal experiences and the information I have gathered, I would strongly advise against shaking breast milk. Instead, gentle swirling or stirring is recommended to mix the layers of milk without damaging its composition. If you find that your breast milk has separated, allowing it to settle and then gently swirling should be sufficient to remix it. This will help ensure that your baby receives all the necessary nutrients and avoids any potential aversions or digestive issues.

Shaking breast milk is not recommended due to the negative effects it can have on the flavor, nutrient content, and potential risk of colic. As a mother, I have learned firsthand the importance of handling breast milk with care. Gentle swirling or stirring is a better alternative to ensure the milk is well-mixed without compromising its quality.