The Shotgun vs Bear Debate: What Really Works?

When it comes to dealing with bears, many people often assume that pointing a shotgun loaded with birdshot at the animal is a good idea. However, this is a common misconception that could lead to disastrous consequences. In reality, usng target or bird-hunting shot to chase away bears is an ineffective solution that can cause more harm than good.

Bears have relatively thin skin, and shotgun ammunition can be extremely harmful and even lethal. While birdshot may seem like a good option for short-range defense, it is not powerful enough to stop a bear in its tracks. The pellets from birdshot do not penetrate deeply enough to cause significant damage to the bear’s vital organs. As a result, the bear may still be able to attack even after being hit with birdshot.

Fortunately, there are many other cartridges that can take down a black bear. For short-range work, the .45-70 Govt., the .30-30 Win., or even a 12-gauge slug will all do the trick. A slug loaded 12 gauge shotgun is good bear medicine. Just make sure you run full house 2 3/4″ or 3″ magnum loads – don’t go for those “reduced recoil” home defense shells.

The 12-gauge slug is a powerful round that can stop a bear in its tracks. It has a large diameter and delivers a massive amount of energy upon impact. The slug can penetrate deep into the bear’s vital organs, causing significant damage and stopping the animal quickly. It is also accurate at short ranges, making it an excellent choice for defending against a charging bear.

Another great option for bear defense is a short 16″ barreled lever-action rifle in a “guide gun” configuration in .45/70. This rifle is powerful and accurate at short ranges, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer a firearm over a shotgun.

When it comes to defending against bears, using birdshot or target shot with a shotgun is not an effective solution. These rounds are not powerful enough to stop a charging bear and could actually lead to more harm than good. Instead, opt for a powerful round such as a 12-gauge slug or a lever-action rifle in .45/70 for effective bear defense. Always practice safety when dealing with bears and be sure to follow all local laws and regulations regarding firearms.

Is A Shotgun Good Against Bears?

It is not recommended to use a shotgun as a means of defense against bears. While it may be commonly believed that shotgun ammunition can effectively scare away bears, this is not entirely true. In fact, bird or target hunting shot is not an efficient solution and can lead to unintended and dangerous consequences.

Bears have relatively thin skin, and shotgun ammunition can cuse severe harm and in some cases, it may even prove to be lethal. Therefore, it is advisable to use bear spray instead of a shotgun when it comes to self-defense against bears. Bear spray is a specially designed type of pepper spray that can be highly effective in deterring bears by creating an unpleasant sensation in their eyes and nose.

Bear spray is also considered to be a non-lethal and more humane way of deterring bears, as it does not cause any long-term damage to the animal. while a shotgun may seem like a reasonable means of defense against bears, it is not a recommended option due to its potential lethality and ineffectiveness.

bear 1686471767

Can You Hunt Bear With A 12 Gauge?

It is possible to hunt a bear with a 12-gauge shotgun. The 12-gauge shotgun is a powerful firearm that can take down a bear at close range. However, it is important to use the appropriate ammunition for bear hunting, such as slugs or buckshot. Slugs are solid projectiles that are designed to penetrate deep into the bear’s body, whle buckshot is a cluster of smaller pellets that spread out upon firing and can cause significant damage to vital organs. It is important to note that hunting bears with a shotgun requires a great deal of skill and experience, as bears are strong and dangerous animals that can quickly become aggressive if provoked. Therefore, it is recommended to hunt bears with a rifle chambered in a larger caliber for safer and more effective hunting.

Is A 12 Gauge Good For Bear Defense?

A 12 gauge shotgun loaded with slugs can be a good choice for bear defense. It is important to use full house 2 3/4″ or 3″ magnum loads instead of reduced recoil home defense shells. Additionally, a short 16″ barreled lever action rifle in a “guide gun” configuration in .45/70 can also be an effective option. Both of these firearms provide significant stopping power and can help to deter or neutralize an aggressive bear. It is important to note that proper training and practice are essential for effective use in a bear defense situation.

Will A 12 Gauge Shotgun Take Down A Grizzly Bear?

A 12 gauge shotgun can take down a grizzly bear. The 12 gauge slug is a powerful round that can deliver a massive amount of energy to the target. It is an excellent choice for hunting large game and self-defense against dangerous animals like grizzly bears. However, it should be noted that the effectiveness of the shotgun depends on the shooter’s skill and shot placement. The slug will lose energy quicker over distance due to greater air resistance, so it is recommended to use it at close range. Additionally, it is crucial to use the apropriate shotgun and ammunition for the task, and to follow all safety guidelines and regulations when hunting or defending against a grizzly bear.

bear 1686471770

Conclusion

Using shotgun ammunition to chase away a bear is not an effective solution. It can be extremely harmful and even lethal to the bear due to their relatively thin skin. If you are in a situation where you need to defend yourself against a bear, thre are many other cartridges that can take down a black bear effectively. For short-range work, the .45-70 Govt., the .30-30 Win., or even a 12-gauge slug are all good options. A slug loaded 12 gauge shotgun is a good bear medicine, but it’s important to use full-house 2 3/4″ or 3″ magnum loads and avoid reduced recoil home defense shells. A short 16″ barreled lever action rifle in a “guide gun” configuration in .45/70 is also a good choice. In any case, it’s important to know the proper ammunition to use when defending yourself against a bear to ensure your safety and the safety of the bear.

Photo of author

William Armstrong

William Armstrong is a senior editor with H-O-M-E.org, where he writes on a wide variety of topics. He has also worked as a radio reporter and holds a degree from Moody College of Communication. William was born in Denton, TX and currently resides in Austin.