To Kill or Not to Kill Alexander in Elden Ring

In the game Divinity: Original Sin 2, players have the option to kill Bishop Alexander, a major character in the game. However, doig so may have consequences and lock the player out of his Elden Ring quest line which grants the Shard of Alexander.

If a player chooses to kill Alexander, they must do so in a morally upstanding way. Betraying his trust and attacking him after he is unearthed is not an acceptable option. Instead, players have a chance to kill him on the ship before the escape battle.

To successfully kill Alexander, players must cover his front side in oil. Oil Pots can be crafted using the Nomadic Warrior’s Cookbook, which can be found at the Nomadic Merchant in Siofra River. Once crafted, hit Iron Fist Alexander with one of these pots, then hit him in the rear.

It’s important to note that Ifan must be in the active party when attacking Bishop Alexander at the pier. If Ifan was not present at the fight, he will express displeasure.

Once the Lady Vengeance has been stolen, players will find that Alexander is somehow still alive. This may be due to plot reasons or game mechanics.

Killing Alexander is not a decision to be taken lightly. It’s important to approach the situation in a morally upstanding way and consider the consequences of the action. By following the steps outlined above, players can successfully kill Alexander and potentially acquire the Shard of Alexander, but at the cost of locking themselves out of his quest line.

What Happens If I Kill Alexander In Elden Ring?

If the player decides to betray the trust placed on them and attack Alexander in Elden Ring, it would be considered a morally reprehensible act. Killing Alexander would not only result in the loss of a valuable NPC, but also lock the player out of his Elden Ring quest line, which grants the Shard of Alexander. This means that the player would not be able to progress through this storyline and receive the rewards that come with it. It is important to note that this decision would have consequences for the player’s character and their overall gameplay experience. Therefore, it is advised that the player refrains from attacking Alexander and intead chooses to continue working alongside him to achieve their goals in the game.

bishop alexander divinity original sin 1684401806

Should I Kill Alexander On The Ship?

If you choose to kill Alexander on the ship, it will impact the storyline in several ways. Firstly, it will prevent him from participating in the final battle, which could make it easier for you. However, it will also affect the ending of the game, as Alexander plays a significant role in the final cutscenes. Additionally, killing Alexander may also impact your relationship with other characters, as some may approve or disapprove of your actions. Ultimately, the decision to kill Alexander on the ship is up to you and your playstyle, but it is important to considr the potential consequences before making a choice.

How Do You Kill Alexander?

To kill Iron Fist Alexander, you’ll need to follow a specific strategy. Firstly, you must cover his front side in oil, which you can create using the Nomadic Warrior’s Cookbook [17]. To obtain this book, you’ll need to visit the Nomadic Merchant in Siofra River. Once you have the cookbook, craft some Oil Pots using the recipe provided.

After crafting the Oil Pots, you’ll need to hit Iron Fist Alexander with one of them. This will cover his front side in oil. Once he’s covered in oil, you must attack him from behind. This is because Iron Fist Alexander has a shield that protects him from frontal attacks. By attacking him from behind, you’ll be able to bypass his shield and deal damage.

The steps to kill Iron Fist Alexander are as follows:

1. Obtain the Nomadic Warrior’s Cookbook [17] from the Nomadic Merchant in Siofra River.
2. Craft Oil Pots using the recipe proided in the cookbook.
3. Hit Iron Fist Alexander with an Oil Pot to cover his front side in oil.
4. Attack Iron Fist Alexander from behind to bypass his shield and deal damage.

How To Stop Ifan From Killing Alexander?

To stop Ifan from killing Alexander, one option is to remove Ifan from the active party before attacking Bishop Alexander at the pier. This can be done by going to the party management screen and selecting another character to replace Ifan. Alternatively, if Ifan is already in the active party and the player wats to prevent him from attacking Alexander, the player can use crowd control spells or abilities to immobilize Ifan or keep him away from Alexander. Another option is to use persuasion during dialogue with Ifan to convince him not to kill Alexander. It’s important to note that Ifan’s attitude towards Alexander may depend on the player’s choices and actions in previous quests, so it’s advisable to consider the consequences of past decisions before attempting to change Ifan’s behavior.

ifan alexander divinity 1684401848

Conclusion

While killing Alexander may seem like a tempting option, it is important to consider the consequences of such an action. Not only wuld it display a lack of morality and betray the trust that Alexander placed on the player, but it would also lock the player out of his Elden Ring quest line and the opportunity to acquire the Shard of Alexander. However, for players who still wish to eliminate him, it is possible to do so on the ship before the escape battle by applying oil to his front side and attacking him from behind. Regardless of the player’s choice, it is important to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision that could potentially have lasting effects on the game’s storyline and the player’s experience overall.

Photo of author

William Armstrong

William Armstrong is a senior editor with H-O-M-E.org, where he writes on a wide variety of topics. He has also worked as a radio reporter and holds a degree from Moody College of Communication. William was born in Denton, TX and currently resides in Austin.