Is selling to C.J. worth it in Animal Crossing: New Horizons? This is a question that many players may ask themselves when deciding whether to sell their fish to C.J. or not. The answer really depends on a few factors, so let’s dive in and explore the pros and cons.
Firstly, let’s talk about the prices C.J. offers for fish. When you sell a fish to C.J., you will generally get a higher price than what you would receive at Nook’s Cranny. For example, the Freshwater Goby sells for 400 Bells at Nook’s Cranny, but C.J. will offer you 600 Bells for it. This price increase can be quite significant for some fish, especially the rarer ones.
One of the main advantages of selling fish to C.J. is the potential for higher profits. Certain fish, like the Giant Snakehead, can fetch a price of 8,250 Bells from C.J., compared to the 5,500 Bells you would get at Nook’s Cranny. If you are looking to maximize your earnings, selling these high-value fish to C.J. can be a great strategy.
Another benefit of selling to C.J. is that he will buy any fish from you, regardless of whether it is currently in season or not. This can be particularly useful if you have caught a fish that is out of season and you don’t want to wait to sell it. By selling it to C.J., you can still make a profit on it, rather than having to store it indefinitely or sell it at a lower price to Nook’s Cranny.
Furthermore, selling to C.J. can also be a good option if you are looking to complete your Critterpedia or museum. By selling fish to him, you can still contribute to your Critterpedia entries and fill up your museum, while also earning some extra Bells.
However, there are a few downsides to consider when selling to C.J. Firstly, he only appears in your town on random days, so you may not always have the opportunity to sell your fish to him. This can be frustrating if you are specifically trying to sell to him for the higher prices.
Additionally, C.J. does not offer a premium price for every fish. Some fish, like the Loach and Catfish, have the same selling price at both Nook’s Cranny and C.J.’s. In these cases, it may not be worth the extra effort to seek out C.J. and sell to him.
Whether or not selling to C.J. is worth it really depends on your individual circumstances and goals in the game. If you are looking to maximize your profits, complete your Critterpedia, or sell out-of-season fish, then selling to C.J. can be a great option. However, if you don’t have access to C.J. or the fish you catch don’t fetch a higher price with him, then it may be more convenient to sell directly to Nook’s Cranny. Ultimately, the choice is yours to make based on what you value most in the game.