In my personal opinion, I find that Dewar’s has a slight edge over Johnnie Walker. Let me explain why.
First, let’s talk about the nose. The nose is an important aspect of any whiskey, as it sets the stage for what’s to come in terms of flavor. When comparing Dewar’s and Johnnie Walker, I found that Dewar’s had a bit more complexity and richness in its nose. It had a pleasant blend of sweet notes, with a hint of smoke that added an extra layer of depth. Johnnie Walker, on the other hand, had a more subdued nose, with less pronounced flavors.
Moving on to the palate, Dewar’s continued to impress. It had a smooth and velvety mouthfeel, with a burst of flavors that danced on my tongue. The smoke was more apparent here, almost like an aromatherapy experience. The sweetness was also more pronounced, which might not be to everyone’s liking, but I personally enjoyed it. Johnnie Walker, while still enjoyable, had a more neutral and refreshing taste. It lacked the same level of complexity and depth that Dewar’s offered.
Now, I must note that taste is subjective, and what I prefer might not be the same as someone else’s preference. Some may find the heavy sweetness of Dewar’s off-putting, while others might enjoy it. Similarly, some may prefer the cleaner and smoother finish of Johnnie Walker.
In the end, it comes down to personal preference. Both Dewar’s and Johnnie Walker are reputable brands that have their own unique qualities. It’s worth trying both to see which one resonates with your taste buds.