In terms of traditional formal dress etiquette, it is generally recommended to button the top button of your shirt when wearing a tie. This creates a more polished and put-together appearance. However, fashion norms have evolved over time, and there are now more relaxed and casual styles that allow for leaving the top button undone.
If you choose to leave the top button unbuttoned, it’s important to consider the overall look you want to achieve. This style works particularly well with a button-down collar, as it helps to maintain a structured and balanced look. The button-down collar can be left unbuttoned or buttoned, depending on your personal preference and the level of formality you want to convey.
When leaving the top button undone, you can also consider knotting the tie just below the unbuttoned button. This adds a stylish touch and keeps the tie in place. It’s important to ensure that the knot isn’t too tight, as this can create a constricted and uncomfortable feeling.
Another factor to consider is the length of your neck. If you have a longer neck, leaving the collar up rather than folded down can help create a more proportional and balanced appearance. This can be particularly effective when wearing a tie with the top button undone, as it adds some visual interest and prevents the neck from looking overly elongated.
To further enhance the relaxed and casual vibe, you can also leave the top collar band and shirt buttons open. This creates a more open and laid-back look, while still maintaining the presence of the tie. However, it’s important to strike a balance and ensure that the overall appearance is still neat and intentional.
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to button the top button with a tie is a matter of personal style and preference. It’s important to consider the occasion, your own comfort, and the overall look you want to achieve. Experimenting with different styles and finding what works best for you can help create a unique and individualized look.
In my personal experience, I have found that leaving the top button unbuttoned with a loosely knotted tie can create a modern and relaxed yet still put-together look. It adds a touch of casualness without compromising on style. However, I also appreciate the classic and traditional look of a fully buttoned shirt with a tight knot. It really depends on the specific outfit, occasion, and personal preference.