Why do flats hurt more than heels?

Answered by James Kissner

Flats can sometimes cause more discomfort than heels due to several reasons. One of the main factors is the effect they have on the Achilles’ tendon. When a person frequently wears high heels, their Achilles’ tendon can become short and tight. This happens because the heel is elevated in high heels, causing the Achilles’ tendon to be in a shortened position for extended periods of time. As a result, the tendon adapts to this position and loses some of its flexibility.

When a person switches from wearing high heels to flats, the Achilles’ tendon is suddenly stretched back into a more neutral position. This sudden change can cause discomfort and pain in the heel and calf area. The tendon is no longer used to being stretched to its full length, and the lack of flexibility can lead to discomfort.

Another reason why flats can be more painful than heels is the lack of proper support. High heels often have built-in arch support and cushioning in the heel area, which can provide some relief and support to the foot. Flats, on the other hand, may lack these features, especially if they are poorly designed or made from low-quality materials. Without proper arch and heel support, flats can exacerbate conditions like plantar fasciitis, which is inflammation of the plantar fascia (the tissue that connects the heel bone to the toes).

Furthermore, flats that do not have good arch support can also lead to overpronation, which is when the foot rolls inward excessively. Overpronation can cause strain on the ligaments and muscles in the foot, leading to discomfort and pain.

It is important to note that not all flats will cause pain, as there are many well-designed flat shoe options available that provide adequate support and cushioning. When choosing flats, it is essential to look for those with features such as arch support, cushioning in the heel area, and flexibility in the sole. Additionally, gradually transitioning from wearing high heels to flats can help the Achilles’ tendon adjust to the change in position, reducing the likelihood of pain and discomfort.

In my personal experience, I have faced discomfort and pain when switching from wearing high heels to flats that lacked proper support. I noticed that my calf muscles and Achilles’ tendon felt strained and tight when wearing flats without cushioning and arch support. However, when I invested in flats with better support and cushioning, the discomfort significantly decreased, and I was able to wear flats without experiencing pain.

To summarize, flats can hurt more than heels because of the effect they have on the Achilles’ tendon, the lack of proper support, and the potential for overpronation. However, not all flats will cause pain, and choosing well-designed flats with adequate support can help alleviate discomfort.