What’s the difference between tenebrism and chiaroscuro?

Answered by Tom Adger

Tenebrism and chiaroscuro are both artistic techniques that involve the use of strong contrasts between light and shadow. These techniques are commonly associated with the works of Baroque painters, who used them to create dramatic and emotional effects in their art.

Chiaroscuro, which means “light-dark” in Italian, focuses on creating a sense of depth and volume through the use of light and shadow. Artists who employ chiaroscuro carefully manipulate the distribution of light and shadow to create a three-dimensional effect in their artwork. They often use a single light source, such as a candle or a spotlight, to cast strong shadows and highlight certain areas of the composition.

One of the most famous artists known for his use of chiaroscuro is the Italian painter Caravaggio. His works, such as “The Calling of St. Matthew” and “The Conversion of St. Paul,” are characterized by their intense contrasts between light and dark. Caravaggio’s use of chiaroscuro not only adds depth to his paintings but also enhances the dramatic impact of the scenes he depicts.

Tenebrism, on the other hand, takes chiaroscuro to the extreme by emphasizing the darkness and minimizing the areas of light. The term “tenebrism” derives from the Italian word “tenebroso,” meaning dark or gloomy. In tenebrist paintings, the contrast between light and shadow is even more extreme than in chiaroscuro. The dark areas in tenebrist works are often pitch black, creating a sense of mystery and foreboding.

A notable artist associated with tenebrism is the Spanish painter Francisco de Zurbarán. His painting “Agnus Dei” is a prime example of tenebrist technique, with the lamb illuminated by a single light source amidst a dark and shadowy background. The use of tenebrism in this painting not only creates a sense of drama but also adds a spiritual and contemplative atmosphere.

The main difference between chiaroscuro and tenebrism lies in the treatment of shadows. Chiaroscuro uses light and shadow to create depth and volume, while tenebrism embraces the darkness and emphasizes the extreme contrast between light and shadow. Both techniques are powerful tools for creating dramatic and emotionally charged artwork, but tenebrism takes the concept of chiaroscuro to a more extreme and intense level.