Well, let’s delve into the realm of “what if” and explore the possibility of Ned Stark becoming the king of Westeros. In order to assess this scenario, we need to consider a few key factors.
Firstly, let’s examine the nature of Robert Baratheon’s claim to the throne. Robert’s Rebellion was primarily fueled by his desire to rescue Lyanna Stark, who was allegedly abducted by Rhaegar Targaryen. However, this premise could be manipulated to paint the conflict as a Stark vs Targaryen struggle, with Ned Stark leading the charge against the Targaryen dynasty.
If Ned had chosen to seize the throne, he would have needed to defeat or persuade Robert to relinquish his claim. Ned was a skilled warrior, renowned for his prowess in combat, but defeating Robert in single combat would have been a monumental challenge. Therefore, persuasion would likely have been the more viable option.
Ned Stark was known for his honor and integrity, which earned him the loyalty and respect of many noble houses. If he presented a convincing argument that the rebellion had been a Stark vs Targaryen conflict, he could have rallied the loyalist houses to his cause. This would have given him a significant power base to challenge Robert’s claim.
Furthermore, Ned’s close relationship with Robert could have been a valuable asset in swaying him to step aside. The two were like brothers and had fought side by side during the rebellion. If Ned could demonstrate that he would be a just and capable ruler, Robert might have been willing to abdicate in favor of his dear friend.
Of course, there would have been significant challenges and obstacles in Ned’s path to the throne. The political landscape of Westeros is treacherous, and many powerful houses would have opposed his ascension. Ned would have needed to navigate these intricate alliances and rivalries, making strategic alliances and winning over influential houses to his cause.
Additionally, there is the matter of Ned’s own reluctance to rule. Throughout the series, Ned is portrayed as a man more comfortable in the role of a loyal advisor rather than a ruler. His sense of duty and honor often overshadowed personal ambition. It is possible that even if the opportunity presented itself, Ned may have declined the throne, seeing it as a burden rather than a prize.
While it is plausible that Ned Stark could have potentially become king, it would have required a delicate balance of persuasion, strategic alliances, and the manipulation of historical narratives. Ned’s honor, integrity, and relationships could have provided him with the necessary tools to challenge Robert’s claim and rally support. However, it is also important to consider Ned’s own reluctance to rule and the challenges he would have faced in the cutthroat world of Westerosi politics.